---
title: "Case File 1031: The Pallet Count That Was Off by One, Every Night"
description: Two investigators with flashlights, one pallet count that is off by exactly one, and a loading dock that knows more than it is saying. A Halloween case file.
---

[Skip to main content](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/blog/case-file-1031-the-pallet-count-that-was-off-by-one#main-content)

LICENSED · BONDED · DECEASEDDUSK TO DAWN · SEVEN NIGHTS A WEEK

★ NOW HAUNTING OFFICE PARKS ★ ★ THE INTERCOM POSSESSION IS HERE ★ ★ SIGN MY GUESTBOOK ★ ★ NO BRIDGES ★★ NOW HAUNTING OFFICE PARKS ★ ★ THE INTERCOM POSSESSION IS HERE ★ ★ SIGN MY GUESTBOOK ★ ★ NO BRIDGES ★

Pause

[![](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/sleepy-hollow-security/images/shield-animated.svg) Sleepy Hollow Security](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/)

Menu

- [Services](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/services)

    - [After-Hours Haunting](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/after-hours-haunting)
    - [Small-Premises Haunting](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/small-premises-haunting)
    - [Wide-Area Haunting](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/wide-area-haunting)
    - [All services and prices](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/services)
- [How it works](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/how-the-haunt-works)
- [About](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/about)
- [Careers](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/careers)
- [The Gazette](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/blog)
- [Request a ride-through](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/book-a-ride-through)

[The Hollow Gazette](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/blog)

[Case file](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/blog/tag/case-files)

# Case File 1031: The Pallet Count That Was Off by One, Every Night

Two investigators with flashlights, one pallet count that is off by exactly one, and a loading dock that knows more than it is saying. A Halloween case file.

 By [The Headless Horseman](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/blog/author/headless-horseman) · Oct 27, 2026, 9:00:00 AM

Two visitors in dark coats arrived at the distribution dock just after midnight, each carrying a flashlight and a very serious expression. They had been called about a pallet count. It had been off by exactly one, every night, for six weeks.

![The Forklift Phantom at a warehouse forklift](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/hubfs/The%20Forklift%20Phantom.jpeg)

## The interviews

Dock supervisor Walter Nakamura was the first to be questioned. He had counted the pallets himself, he said, three nights running, and the scanner and the clipboard agreed with each other and disagreed with the truck manifest. "One extra," he said. "Never two. Never zero. Always one."

Inventory lead Mateo Brannigan was next. He had checked the software, the scanner, the labels, and the spreadsheet. He had also checked the spreadsheet's spreadsheet. "The number is wrong," he told the investigators, "and it is wrong in a very disciplined way."

Neither man had a theory that fit. Walter suspected the scanner. Mateo suspected Walter. Both of them suspected the night shift, which is the traditional place to look, and which also had no theory. The investigators wrote all of this down and asked to see the dock at midnight.

## The staging lane

The investigators walked the dock slowly, flashlights low. At staging lane four, the scanner chirped. There was nothing on the floor. The light swept left. The scanner chirped again.

The answer was the Loading Dock Lurker. It stands in the staging lane every night after the last truck leaves, and the scanner had been counting it as a pallet. The count was corrected by one. Mateo reset the scanner to ignore the lane, and the number has been right ever since. Nothing was stolen. The senior investigator wrote "no further action" in her notebook, underlined it twice, and looked slightly disappointed.

## The dock next door

Then came the part of the file that is not funny. The investigators also visited the dock next door, which we do not haunt. Over the same six weeks, the count there had been off by dozens of pallets. Not one. Dozens. The last truck leaves, the door is not quite latched, and the morning count is short. Nobody there has an explanation, and nobody was there overnight to give one.

Walter Nakamura looked over the fence at it for a while. "Same trucks," he said. "Same time. Same street." He did not say anything else.

For a dock like the second one, the Lurker is the service to read about: one soul per dock per year, or one pallet, delivered on time, each quarter. Larger sites can find the full set on the [wide-area haunting](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/wide-area-haunting) page. For another case that ended with an alibi, read [Forty-Two TVs Turned On at 2:12 A.M. and We Have an Alibi](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/blog/forty-two-tvs-turned-on-at-2-12-am-and-we-have-an-alibi).

## Case closed, with a guarantee

Every intruder runs off empty-handed, or the night is free. Claims are accepted within 30 days. Ask any other security company what they promise. Ours is in writing, and no other security company offers one.

The deadline on this case file is Halloween night. Request a ride-through now, and there is time to sign before it.

[Request a ride-through](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/night-shift-industrial)

Take a ride-through and sign by Halloween night, and the first month is free.

**Filed under:** [Case files](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/blog/tag/case-files), [Tall tales](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/blog/tag/tall-tales)

## Every intruder runs off empty-handed, or the night is free.

[Request a ride-through ▸](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/book-a-ride-through)

[Home](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/) [Services](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/services) [About](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/about) [Careers](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/careers) [Gazette](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/blog) [Terms](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/terms-of-service) [Privacy](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/privacy-policy)

## Guestbook

"Stapler floated. Left immediately. 10/10." *– Anonymous Burglar*

"Great service, very cold." *– Main St. Pharmacy*

"Please stop the footsteps in Aisle 9." *– Store Manager (we will not)*

![Sleepy Hollow Security mark](https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/hubfs/raw_assets/public/sleepy-hollow-security/images/shield-animated.svg)

## Unique visitors this month · October 2026

001430

POWERED BY  
ECTOPLASM VALID HTML 4.01  
(PROBABLY) HAUNTED  
WEBRING ◄ ►

Best viewed at dusk in Netscape Navigator 4.0 at 800x600 · Last updated by Ezekiel, Webmaster · Bridges not crossed · © 2026

---

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "The Headless Horseman",
    "url" : "https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/blog/author/headless-horseman"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-10-27T13:00:00.837Z",
  "datePublished" : "2026-10-27T13:00:00.000Z",
  "headline" : "Case File 1031: The Pallet Count That Was Off by One, Every Night",
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/blog/case-file-1031-the-pallet-count-that-was-off-by-one",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://www.sleepyhollowsecurity.com/hubfs/sleepy-hollow-icon.svg"
    }
  }
}
```